A political storm is quietly gathering in Rivers State as the Senate begins screening President Bola Tinubu’s nominees for key commissions under the emergency rule imposed in the state.

At the centre of the controversy is the nomination of Dr. Michael Ekpai Odey, a Cross River State indigene, to serve as Chairman of the Rivers State Independent Electoral Commission (RVSIEC)—a move raising serious legal and constitutional concerns.

Dr. Odey’s nomination came as part of a larger list of appointments forwarded by President Tinubu to the Senate, read by Senate President Godswill Akpabio on June 12.

While most nominees to the Rivers State Civil Service Commission, Rivers State Local Government Service Commission, and RVSIEC cleared initial security screenings without issue, Odey’s state of origin triggered alarm bells during deliberations.

Since the declaration of emergency rule in Rivers State, the National Assembly has taken over the functions of the State House of Assembly.

President Tinubu, in separate letters forwarded to the President of the Senate, Godswill Akpabio, and read at plenary on the 12th of June, 2025, sought appointments of nominees into the Rivers State Electoral Commission, Rivers State Local Government Service Commission, and Rivers State Civil Service Commission.

Former Chief of Naval Staff Ibok Ekwe Ibas, also from Cross River State, currently serves as the sole administrator of the state—a rare situation where both the administrative and proposed electoral leadership are outsiders.

Critics argue that this setup could compromise the independence of the state’s electoral body, potentially undermining local political autonomy.

Chairman of the Senate Ad-hoc Committee on Oversight of Emergency Rule, Senator Opeyemi Bamidele, acknowledged concerns over Odey’s nomination.

Speaking during the screening on Tuesday, Bamidele said the committee would review the legality of appointing a non-indigene to lead RVSIEC in light of the laws that establish the commission.

“This is a matter that touches on the foundation of electoral credibility and constitutional boundaries,” Bamidele stated, promising a thorough examination of the issue before the Senate resumes plenary next week.

Under Nigerian law, state electoral commissions are expected to be headed by persons with ties to the state to ensure trust and independence.

With both the sole administrator and the electoral commission nominee hailing from the same outside state, critics warn of a federal overreach that may sow deeper political discord in the oil-rich region.

Civil society groups and opposition figures are already beginning to question the intent and long-term implications of centralising Rivers State’s governance in the hands of non-indigenes, especially in sensitive areas like electoral administration.

In contrast, the nominations for the Rivers State Civil Service Commission and Local Government Service Commission sailed through without controversy.

Notable nominees include Dr. Barikor Livinus Baribuma as Chairman of the Civil Service Commission, and Israel N. Amadi heading the Local Government Service Commission.

Despite no petitions or red flags from security agencies against any of the 19 nominees, Dr. Odey’s nomination remains the most contentious, and the Senate’s decision could set a powerful precedent for how federal authority is exercised during emergency rule in states.