The Guardian
Email YouTube Facebook Instagram Twitter WhatsApp

Supreme Court dismisses Wike’s suit against Rivers tribunal


Nyesom-WikeThe Supreme Court yesterday dismissed an interlocutory appeal filed by Rivers State Governor Nyesom Wike and the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), challenging the propriety and power of the governorship election petition tribunal to sit in Abuja instead of Port Harcourt, the state capital.

Delivering its verdict on Wike’s appeal, the apex court held that it lacked merit and substance and was thrown out in its entirety.

In the judgment delivered by Justice Amiru Sanusi, the court said the decision of the said tribunal to sit in Abuja rather than Port Harcourt was in order because it was taken as a security measure. Justice Sanusi said that President of the Court of Appeal, Justice Zainab Bukachuwa’s decision for the tribunal to sit in Abuja was to ensure protection of lives of the tribunal members and other stakeholders.

He held that there was compelling evidence of security challenges prevailing in Rivers State as at the time the panel was constituted. He further held that the court cannot be bound in the decision in Ibori’s case which was cited by the appellant.

The court further noted that in the Ibori case, it was not the President of the Court of Appeal that relocated the tribunal and that there was no situation of insecurity as at then.

The court’s judgment reads in part: “But in the instant case, it was the President of the Court of Appeal that relocated the tribunal to Abuja because of insecurity, it was this situation that demanded for a doctrine of necessity which made the President of the Court to relocate the tribunal to Abuja to protect the lives of the members of the panel.
“I agree with the Court of Appeal that the President of the Court of Appeal is right in relocating the panel to Abuja.

“On the whole, I hold that the tribunal was properly constituted by the President of the Court of Appeal even without consultation with the Chief Judge of Rivers State or the President of the Customary Court‎, even though, as at then, there was no Chief Judge, and there was no President of the Customary Court. The consultation here is not as to the venue of the sitting but to get judges in Rivers State that will be part of the various election petition tribunals.

“It is necessary to protect members of the panel from the theatre of war to where their lives will be secured.

“The President of the Court of Appeal has the power and has judiciously utilized the power. The panel is properly constituted and it is not bereft of jurisdiction to hear the petition of the petitioner. The appeal lacks merit and it is hereby dismissed.”

The tribunal which sat in Abuja had last Saturday nullified the April 11 governorship election which returned Wike of the PDP as governor and ordered the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC} to conduct a fresh election within 90 days.
However, before the Saturday judgment by the tribunal, Wike’s appeal had been pending before the apex court, wherein he was challenging the relocation of the tribunal to Abuja.

At the Court of Appeal, the panel of justices had upheld the relocation of the tribunal to Abuja on ground of insecurity in Rivers State. Dissatisfied, Wike had gone to the apex court, seeking to set aside the judgment of the Court of Appeal and the ruling of the petition tribunal on the jurisdiction. But a full panel of the apex court in their unanimous decision dismissed the appeal by Wike and PDP for lacking in merit.

Receive News Alerts on Whatsapp: +2348136370421

  • Rev. Fr. Fadele Emmanuel

    Politicians in Nigeria should allow our systems to run smoothly. Many of them are either mischievous or out rightly ignorant. Their unguarded statements against courts rulings should be sanctioned accordingly especially those highly placed among them to serve as deterrent to their ilks. We must make things work here if not we have no nation.

    • Ikenna P

      Your comment is lopsided. The ruling party is manipulating the justice system to its advantage. Rather than addressing the looming economy crisis, the party is victimizing opposition parties’ members. Believe it or not, the APC’s antics would be exposed in 2016.

      • Tope

        What do you have to say about Delta State election tribunal in which the PDP governor won the case?

    • Bigzy

      Which Court ruling? The Judges are in the pocket of the politicians. Or are you telling me that you are unaware of this fact?

  • Dr. Jegede, Ajibade Ebenezer

    This is a very good development. The days of misbehavior and rule of thumb is over. We must force ourselves to do things right and fairness should guide our approach to issues. Sincerity is of utmost importance and this court in my view has risen up to that challenge. How I wish that Nigerian courts will continue to be upright and dispense justice without encumbrances with negative extra legalistic considerations.More of this is expected in time to come. Long live Nigeria.

    • Olubode Samuel

      I agree with you. It’s unlike the era before now when Fayose was allowed to do what he liked in Ekiti State.

  • Yemi Amodu

    Sterling Homes ltd selling Plots and Acres of Land………….

    Hebron garden estate is owned by Sterling homes Ltd and it’s
    completely free from “omo-onile” and government acquisition. Land
    mass: more than 10acres. Land type: dry, sandy and leveled. Location: Lekki,
    about 6minutes drive to Eleko beach and 15minutes drive to Lekki free trade
    zone. There are several notable Landmarks before the estate. These include, The
    Lagos Business School, Crown Estate, Farapark, Sapphire Garden, Green Springs
    School and Shares immediate environment with Mayfair Gardens and Beechwood
    Estate & lots more. PAYMENT PLAN FOR A PLOT: *Smart plan: Outright payment
    #2.8m. *Easy Plan: ‎#3m. Spread #210,000 for 10months after the initial deposit
    of #900,000. Contact Yemi Amodu @ Sterling Homes LTD for site inspections and
    more information: Plot 2, River Valley Estate, Ojodu Berger. Mobile 08136119495

    Havilah park and garden is an estate located about 6mins
    drive off the Lagos-Ibadan expressway. It’s about 25mins drive to Berger
    bus-stop. The estate is fenced with a gate house, and our ultra- modern
    borehole is already in place. The price of a plot is #630,000 outright, and we
    still have other installment plan also. For more information and site
    inspection call Yemi Amodu @ Sterling Homes LTD: Plot 2, River Valley Estate,
    Ojodu Berger, Lagos. Mobile: 07084546154, 08136119495

    Moriah park is situated at Agbowa, Ikorodu. The estate is
    facing the Lagos state housing scheme popularly called Fashola estate. It’s
    fenced round with a gate house and an industrial borehole has been constructed
    at the site as well. It’s selling for a promotional offer of #750,000 outright,
    though we still have other installment payment option. For more information and
    site inspection, call Yemi @ Sterling Homes LTD: Plot 2, River Valley Estate,
    Ojodu Berger, Lagos. Mobile: 07084546154, 08136119495