Onion, garlic ‘cure’ for antibiotic-resistant diabetic foot ulcers
A 1,000-year-old medieval remedy containing onion, garlic, wine, and bile salts could be used to treat diabetic foot ulcers that are resistant to antibiotics. United Kingdom (UK) scientists have turned to the natural historic remedy known as Bald’s eyesalve to fill a gap in the antibiotic market.
The remedy targets biofilms – slimy layers made from a community of microbes – that show resistance to antibiotic drugs currently on the market.
The mixture’s bacteria-killing activity extends to five bacterial species commonly found in diabetic foot ulcers and other wounds, the researchers report.
Natural medieval potions such as Bald’s eyesalve could be an answer to antimicrobial resistance (AMR) – when bacteria adapt in response to modern antibacterial medicines.
Bald’s eyesalve is an ‘ancient-biotic’ that requires the combination of all ingredients for potent activity against bacterial strains. It includes bile salts, which are made in the liver to aid the digestion of fats but are also sold as supplements.
The recipe stems from Bald’s Leechbook, an Old English medical textbook likely compiled in the ninth century. The new was study published in the journal Scientific Reports.
Bacteria can exist either as individual planktonic cells or as a multicellular collective known as a biofilm. Biofilms are harder for antibiotic drugs to eradicate because they secrete a matrix made of sugar molecules, which form a kind of armour that acts as a physical and chemical barrier.
Biofilms are communities of microbial cells naturally accumulate on a variety of surfaces – from plastic medical equipment to the surface of the human body.
A biofilm essentially helps protect bacteria from antibiotics, making them much harder to treat.
Biofilm eradication often requires somewhere between 100 to 1,000 times higher antibiotic concentrations than the same bacteria growing planktonically – as individual free-floating cells – to be effective.
Biofilm infections of wounds (such as burns, diabetic foot ulcers), medical implants (artificial joints, catheters), the lungs (like cystic fibrosis) and other body sites impose a major health and economic burden.
Non-healing, infected foot ulcers, which can be a complication of diabetes, provide an especially sobering example and are particularly difficult to target using antibiotics.
Even if the infection is apparently successfully treated, there is a high chance of recurrence and an estimated 50 per cent of those affected die within five years of ulcer development.
“We have shown that a medieval remedy made from onion, garlic, wine, and bile can kill a range of problematic bacteria grown both planktonically and as biofilms,” said Dr. Freya Harrison from the University of Warwick.
“Because the mixture did not cause much damage to human cells in the lab, or to mice, we could potentially develop a safe and effective antibacterial treatment from the remedy.”
The University of Warwick worked with microbiologists, chemists, pharmacists, data analysts and medievalists at Nottingham and in the United States (U.S.).
Together, they reconstructed the 1,000-year-old medieval remedy containing onion, garlic, wine, and bovine bile salts, known as Bald’s eyesalve. Each of Bald’s eyesalve ingredients has known antimicrobial properties or compounds.
The garlic and onions used to make the mixture, which were purchased from supermarkets, had their outer skin removed and were finely chopped.
Equal volumes of garlic and onion were crushed together with a mortar and pestle for two minutes before being combined with equal volumes of organic dry white wine, (11% ABV, sourced from Avalon Vineyard in Shepton Mallet, Somerset) and bovine bile salts, which are usually given to help with the digestion of fats.
The mixture was stored in sterilised glass bottles in the dark at 7.2°F (4°C) for nine days, after which it was strained and centrifuged for five minutes and then filtered before being applied to bacteria.
The formula had promising antibacterial activity and caused low levels of damage to human cells, the team found.
It was found to eliminate five pathogens, including Staphylococcus aureus, which can cause serious infections like blood poisoning and toxic shock syndrome.
All five of the bacteria can be found in the biofilms that infect diabetic foot ulcers and can be resistant to antibiotic treatment.
These debilitating infections can lead to amputation to avoid the risk of the bacteria spreading to the blood, known as bacteremia.
Bald’s eyesalve remedy was effective against a range of Gram-negative and Gram-positive wound pathogens in planktonic culture.
This activity is maintained against the following pathogens grown as biofilms:
1. Acinetobacter baumanii – commonly associated with infected wounds in combat troops returning from conflict zones.
2. Stenotrophomonas maltophilia – commonly associated with respiratory infections in humans.
3. Staphylococcus aureus – a common cause of skin infections including abscesses, respiratory infections such as sinusitis, and food poisoning.
4. Staphylococcus epidermidis – a common cause of infections involving indwelling foreign devices such as a catheter, surgical wound infections, and bacteremia in immune-compromised patients.
5. Streptococcus pyogenes – causes numerous infections in humans including pharyngitis, tonsillitis, scarlet fever, cellulitis, rheumatic fever and post-streptococcal glomerulonephritis.
The team then conducted an assessment of whether any individual ingredient or the sulphur-containing compound allicin (from garlic) could explain its effectiveness.
Garlic contains a compound called allicin, which is produced when its cloves are crushed or chopped, and can be toxic in high concentrations.
The chemical compound is described as providing a natural antimicrobial defence by inhibiting activity of a key bacterial enzyme called Deoxy ribonucleic Acid (DNA) gyrase, which is needed for efficient cell division.
However, garlic alone has no activity against biofilms, and therefore the anti-biofilm activity of Bald’s eyesalve cannot be attributed to a single ingredient and requires the combination of all ingredients to achieve full activity.
Wine, bile or onion alone was also much less effective than the full remedy.
Curiously, wine possessed very limited antimicrobial activity, and could not kill S. aureus in biofilms.
Despite this, its absence from the full remedy was shown to cause a large drop in activity against S. aureus biofilms.
The role of wine in the full recipe may be more to do with its physical properties, such as its ethanol content or low pH.
Ethanol is a well-known extraction solvent and may allow better diffusion through biofilms, while the lower pH may activate pH-dependent anti-bacterial compounds.
Further work is needed to explain the exact combination of natural products responsible for the anti-biofilm activity.
“Most antibiotics that we use today are derived from natural compounds, but our work highlights the need to explore not only single compounds but mixtures of natural products for treating biofilm infections,” said Harrison.
“We think that future discovery of antibiotics from natural products could be enhanced by studying combinations of ingredients, rather than single plants or compounds.
“In this first instance, we think this combination could suggest new treatments for infected wounds, such as diabetic foot and leg ulcers.”
When considering natural products as a potential source of anti-biofilm agents, there’s the possibility that any success they have could rely on creating “a cocktail of different products,” the researchers say.
In previous research, Professor Christina Lee, from the School of English at the University of Nottingham, had examined Bald’s Leechbook, an Old English leather-bound volume in the British Library, to see if any of the remedies really worked.
The Leechbook is widely thought of as one of the earliest known medical textbooks and contains Anglo-Saxon medical advice and recipes for medicines, salves and treatments.
“Bald’s eyesalve underlines the significance of medical treatment throughout the ages,” Professor Lee said.“It shows that people in Early Medieval England had at least some effective remedies. “The collaboration which has informed this project shows the importance of the arts in interdisciplinary research.”