The Nigerian Medical Association (NMA) and the Medical and Dental Consultants Association of Nigeria (MDCAN) have opposed the Senate’s proposal to impose jail terms and fines on health workers who refuse to treat patients requiring emergency medical attention.
The associations argued that criminalising doctors and other health professionals for systemic failures beyond their control would not address the challenges confronting the health sector but could further weaken the workforce and restrict patients’ access to emergency services.
The proposal comes amid concerns over patients’ difficulties accessing emergency treatment, particularly in hospitals lacking essential equipment, medical supplies and personnel, or demanding payment before providing care.
While affirming that every Nigerian deserves emergency medical treatment irrespective of financial status, the associations maintained that healthcare providers must have the resources and infrastructure to meet this obligation.
They urged the National Assembly to prioritise enforcement of the National Health Act, 2014, warning that additional punitive measures could accelerate the migration of doctors and other health professionals.
In a statement, NMA President, Prof. Afekhide Omoti, blamed inadequate government funding, poor hospital infrastructure and shortages of medical personnel for persistent gaps in emergency healthcare delivery.
Omoti said the National Health Act already prohibited the denial of emergency medical care, adding that the major challenge was the failure to implement its provisions and create an enabling environment for compliance.
He cited Section 6 of the Act, which established the Basic Health Care Provision Fund (BHCPF) and provided for emergency medical treatment. However, he said implementation of the emergency treatment component remained inadequate, leaving hospitals unable to access expected refunds and reimbursements for services rendered.
He described the arrangement as unsustainable, noting that hospitals were expected to shoulder the cost of emergency treatment despite their limited resources.
The NMA president said it was unfair to impose criminal liability on healthcare workers and hospitals when the government had failed to provide the resources needed to deliver emergency services.
He identified poor remuneration, unfavourable working conditions, inadequate infrastructure, insecurity and excessive workloads as factors driving the shortage and migration of Nigerian doctors and nurses.
According to him, many hospitals operate with dangerously inadequate personnel, leaving available doctors to manage overwhelming patient loads.
The association also cited shortages of oxygen, essential drugs, blood and blood products, resuscitation equipment, medical consumables and functional ambulances, questioning how doctors could provide effective emergency care without these life-saving resources.
On accountability, the NMA maintained that deliberate and unjustifiable refusal to provide emergency treatment, where personnel, facilities and resources were available, should attract appropriate professional and legal sanctions.
Similarly, MDCAN President, Prof. Chidi Ndukuba, said no Nigerian should die because of an inability to pay for treatment, insisting that emergency care was a right, not a privilege.
He warned that criminalising doctors for systemic failures they did not create would not save lives but could further undermine the healthcare system.
Ndukuba faulted the absence of a functional national emergency medical services system, noting that patients were still transported to hospitals in wheelbarrows, tricycles and private vehicles, sometimes arriving hours after emergencies occurred.
He cited Section 20(1) of the National Health Act, 2014, which prohibits healthcare providers, health workers and health establishments from refusing emergency medical treatment for any reason.
However, he described the existing framework as inadequate because it imposed obligations on healthcare providers without equipping them with the means to fulfil them.
He said the BHCPF and its Emergency Medical Treatment gateway were chronically underfunded, poorly disbursed and inaccessible to many public and private healthcare facilities when patients needed urgent treatment.
Ndukuba also identified inadequate funding, personnel shortages, unpaid hospital bills, insecurity, violence against health workers and poor medical equipment as obstacles to emergency healthcare delivery.
He warned that jail terms for circumstances beyond doctors’ control could accelerate the exodus of medical professionals, force hospitals to close emergency units and encourage defensive medical practice.
MDCAN urged the National Assembly to ensure adequate funding of emergency treatment, improve hospital infrastructure and recruit and retain healthcare professionals.
It called for an adequately funded emergency medical treatment system with automatic, cashless reimbursement to healthcare facilities. The association also advocated a national emergency medical service with a single toll-free number, trained paramedics, equipped ambulances across the 774 local government areas and an effective referral system.
The council further urged government to increase health sector funding to at least 15 per cent of the national budget, in line with the Abuja Declaration, while improving security, welfare, hazard allowances and life insurance for health workers.
MDCAN said genuine cases of refusal to provide emergency treatment should be investigated by the relevant councils and hospital management, with administrative and civil sanctions imposed where deliberate misconduct was established.