By Saheed Fuhad
Continued from yesterday
There are also programmes such as the Adolescent Girls Initiative for Learning and Empowerment and the Nigeria for Women Programme Scale-Up. These are not necessarily meaningless projects. Healthcare, education, irrigation, electricity and women’s economic empowerment are legitimate development priorities. Some have identifiable beneficiaries and measurable objectives.
The concern, however, is whether the government is demonstrating sufficiently clear, publicly accessible evidence of implementation, measurable results, independent evaluation and long-term financial returns commensurate with the debt commitments.
For example, when a government borrows hundreds of millions of dollars for human capital development, Nigerians should be able to identify the number of schools improved, the number of healthcare facilities strengthened, the quality of services delivered and the measurable improvement in educational and health outcomes.
When hundreds of millions are borrowed for power and irrigation, the public should know the specific infrastructure delivered, the additional electricity generated, the hectares of land brought under irrigation and the economic value created. When loans are tied to broad policy objectives such as economic stabilisation, revenue mobilisation, governance improvement and social protection, the government must explain precisely what has changed as a result of the financing and how those changes will generate lasting economic benefits.
The issue is not that these objectives are inherently vague or unnecessary. The issue is that broad policy objectives must not become substitutes for transparent accounting and measurable development outcomes. Nigeria cannot afford to borrow billions of dollars and leave citizens struggling to establish what tangible economic value the country has received in return.
There is an additional concern with policy-based financing: some loans support reforms and budgetary programmes rather than directly financing a revenue-generating physical asset. Such financing may be justified, but it requires particularly strong evidence that the reforms will improve fiscal capacity and deliver lasting public benefits. The ultimate test is simple: will these loans leave Nigeria with a stronger economy capable of repaying them, or will they simply increase the country’s future obligations?
The lessons from countries that borrowed beyond their capacity
Nigeria is certainly not the first country to face the consequences of excessive borrowing, weak revenue mobilisation and poor debt management. The experiences of Sri Lanka, Ghana and Zambia provide important lessons.
In April 2022, Sri Lanka defaulted on its external debt obligations for the first time in its history. The crisis did not happen overnight. Years of fiscal deficits, a narrow revenue base, heavy reliance on external borrowing and weaknesses in economic management had left the country vulnerable. The COVID-19 pandemic devastated tourism receipts, while falling foreign-exchange earnings and rising import costs intensified the country’s difficulties.
Sri Lanka eventually experienced severe shortages of essential goods, fuel and medicines, inflation and widespread public protests. It had to seek IMF assistance and negotiate debt restructuring with its creditors. The lesson for Nigeria is that foreign borrowing becomes particularly dangerous when a country lacks sufficient foreign-exchange reserves and a diversified export base to withstand external shocks.
Ghana offers an even more relevant African example. For years, Ghana accessed international capital markets, accumulated public debt and struggled with fiscal deficits. The COVID-19 pandemic and the global economic shocks that followed further weakened its finances. By December 2022, the Ghanaian government announced a suspension of payments on certain external debts and embarked on a major debt restructuring programme.
According to IMF assessments, Ghana’s debt-service-to-revenue ratio reached approximately 127 per cent in 2020. This meant that its debt-service obligations were equivalent to more than the government’s revenue for that year, although the indicator includes debt-service components and must be understood in its fiscal context. The consequences were severe. Ghana restructured domestic debt, negotiated with external creditors and entered an IMF-supported programme. The experience demonstrates that a country can reach a point where its government revenue is insufficient to comfortably meet debt obligations and finance essential public expenditure.
Zambia’s experience is another important warning. The country embarked on an ambitious public investment programme, financed substantially through external borrowing, including non-concessional loans. However, according to the IMF, the resulting investments did not produce sufficient economic growth and government revenue to sustain the rising debt burden.
By the end of 2019, Zambia’s public and publicly guaranteed debt had risen to approximately 105 per cent of GDP, according to the IMF’s subsequent assessment. In November 2020, Zambia defaulted on its Eurobond obligations, becoming the first African country to default during the COVID-19 crisis. The country subsequently entered a prolonged debt restructuring process.
The lesson is clear: borrowing for infrastructure is not automatically productive borrowing. Roads, bridges, power projects and other infrastructure must be properly selected, economically viable, efficiently executed and capable of generating benefits that justify their cost. A country can borrow billions to build infrastructure and still end up in financial distress if the investments fail to produce sufficient economic returns.
These examples are not predictions of Nigeria’s inevitable future. They demonstrate the risks that arise when debt accumulation, weak fiscal capacity, foreign-exchange vulnerability and poor investment returns combine.
The danger of borrowing to repay borrowing
One of the most disturbing developments in debt management is the possibility of entering a cycle in which new loans are contracted to meet obligations arising from previous loans. Borrowing to refinance maturing debt is not automatically irresponsible. Governments routinely refinance debt to manage maturities and reduce financing costs.
However, when refinancing becomes a permanent substitute for revenue generation, economic productivity and fiscal discipline, the country becomes increasingly exposed to creditor confidence and international financial conditions. The danger is that a government may find itself borrowing not to build new economic capacity, but simply to remain financially afloat. This is particularly worrying for Nigeria because of its enormous development needs.
We have millions of children who require quality education, hospitals that need modern equipment, roads that require rehabilitation, farmers who need irrigation and processing facilities, and industries that need reliable electricity. Every naira committed to debt servicing is a naira that cannot simultaneously be spent on these priorities. The opportunity cost is enormous. What happens when the creditors begin to dictate the pace?
There is also a political and economic dimension to foreign indebtedness that Nigerians must understand. When a country becomes heavily dependent on external financing, its economic policy choices can become increasingly constrained by the conditions attached to financing and the need to maintain creditor confidence.
This does not mean every World Bank or IMF loan automatically comes with harmful conditions. Different facilities have different terms, and some are designed to support reforms that governments have independently chosen. However, policy-based loans can involve agreed reform commitments, performance conditions and institutional changes. Nigeria’s own experience with subsidy removal and exchange-rate liberalisation has demonstrated how major economic policy decisions can have far-reaching social consequences.
The government must therefore be transparent about the conditions attached to loans, the obligations being undertaken and the long-term implications for the Nigerian economy. Financial independence is not simply about having a sovereign flag and an elected government.
It also requires sufficient fiscal and economic capacity to make policy choices without being trapped by an unsustainable debt burden.
What Nigeria must do before the problem becomes bigger
The solution is not to stop borrowing altogether. That would be an unrealistic and potentially counterproductive position for a developing country with substantial infrastructure and human development needs. The solution is to borrow more intelligently, spend more transparently and build a stronger productive economy.
Firstly, every major loan should be accompanied by a publicly accessible economic justification, a clear implementation timetable and measurable performance indicators.
Secondly, the government must prioritise investments that expand domestic production, particularly in manufacturing, agriculture, energy, mineral processing and export-oriented industries.
Thirdly, Nigeria must strengthen its non-oil revenue base. A country with an economy of Nigeria’s size should not continue to depend so heavily on a relatively narrow pool of government revenue.
Fourthly, foreign-currency borrowing must be carefully managed against the country’s capacity to earn foreign exchange.
Loans should be structured with due consideration for exchange-rate risks, repayment schedules and the economic returns of the projects being financed. Fifth, there must be stronger legislative oversight and independent auditing of loan utilisation. Nigerians deserve to know how much has been borrowed, how much has been disbursed, what has been delivered and what remains outstanding.
Finally, government must distinguish between borrowing for productive investment and borrowing to finance recurrent expenditure or temporary fiscal relief. The latter may sometimes be necessary, but it cannot become a permanent development strategy.
Concluded.
Fuhad is a broadcast journalist and public affairs analyst. He is currently the head of station at Mainland 98.3fm.