CAS affirms no Rio Olympic Games for Russian athletes
Usain Bolt, Isinbayeva differ on ruling
Russian track and field athletes will remain banned from the Olympics following claims the country ran a state-sponsored doping programme.The Russian Olympic Committee (ROC) and 68 Russian athletes attempted to overturn the suspension, implemented by the body that governs world athletics. But the Court of Arbitration for Sport (Cas) has ruled it can stand.
A handful of Russian athletes could still compete as neutrals at the Rio Games, which starts on August 5.“It’s sad but rules are rules,” said Olympic 100m and 200m champion, Usain Bolt, who is targeting more gold medals in Rio. He said it was important to send a strong message to the dopers.“Doping violations in track and field is getting really bad,” said the Jamaican, 29. “If you cheat or go against the rules, this will scare a lot of people.”
However, Russian pole vaulter, Yelena Isinbayeva, one of the 68 to appeal to Cas, said the ruling was “a blatant political order”, while the Russian Foreign Ministry called it a “crime against sport”.Isinbayeva, the 2012 gold medallist, 34, told the Tass news agency: “Thank you all for this funeral for athletics.”
The International Association of Athletics Federations (IAAF) said it was “pleased Cas has supported its position”, adding that the judgment had “created a level playing field for athletes”.IAAF president, Lord Coe, added: “This is not a day for triumphant statements. I didn’t come into this sport to stop athletes from competing.
“Beyond Rio, the IAAF taskforce will continue to work with Russia to establish a clean safe environment for its athletes so that its federation and team can return to international recognition and competition.”
Separately, the International Olympic Committee (IOC) is considering calls to ban all Russian competitors from the Rio Games following a second report into state-sponsored doping.Some Russian athletes could compete in Rio as neutrals if they meet a number of criteria, including being repeatedly tested outside their homeland.
At least two – 800m runner and doping whistleblower Yuliya Stepanova and US-based long jumper Darya Klishina – have gone down that path.Now the ruling by a three-person Cas panel has cleared the way for others.Cas said the ROC could still nominate athletes to compete as neutrals. However, a Cas spokesman said the panel had expressed concerns that this left “no possibility” for athletes to comply with the criteria.
Three lawyers from Italy, Britain and the United States, widely regarded as amongst the most experienced judges on the court’s list of around 400 approved arbitrators.The chairman was Milan-based Luigi Fumagalli, who also sat on the panel which upheld Fifa’s four-month ban on Uruguay’s Luis Suarez for biting Italian defender Georgio Chiellini opponent at the 2014 World Cup.
Retired judge Robert Reid, from England, has chaired disciplinary committees for the Premier League and sat in judgment of Pakistan cricketer Salman Butt’s failed appeal to Cas against a ban for fixing.Finally, Jeffrey Benz from Los Angeles is a former legal adviser to the United States Olympic Committee.
Why Russian athletes were banned?
Russia was suspended from track and field events by the IAAF in November 2015 following the publication of an independent World Anti-Doping Agency (Wada) report that showed a culture of widespread, state-sponsored doping.Sports minister Vitaly Mutko apologised for Russia’s failure to catch the cheats but stopped short of admitting the scandal had been state-sponsored.
However, another Wada-commissioned report delivered earlier this week – the McLaren report – contained more damaging allegations and suggested senior figures in Russia’s sports ministry were complicit in an organised cover-up.
The report implicated the majority of Olympic sports in the cover-up and claimed that Russian secret service agents were involved in swapping positive urine samples for clean ones.
Following Monday’s publication of the McLaren report, the IOC faced calls to ban all Russian competitors from the 2016 Olympics and will hold an second emergency meeting on Sunday to decide its course of action.
How Russia responded?
The Russian authorities have already suggested that they will look at ways to continue legal action.Following the ruling, sports minister Mutko said Cas had set “a certain precedent” by punishing a collective group for doping offences by individuals.Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov added: “The principle of collective responsibility cannot be acceptable. The news is not very good.”
Culled from BBC Sport
No comments yet